It was composed mostly of bolshevik intellectuals who criticised the leadership of the communist party for excessive. Democratic centralism an overview sciencedirect topics. Sovnarkom sovnarkom is the russian term for council of peoples commissars and became the governing apparatus in russia shortly after the october revolution. Rawls would argue that we liberals should consider a decent democratic centralism to be legitimate because of the ways in which it fulfills the fundamental idea of social cooperation that makes a group count as a people. More often than not, enemies of marxism and selfproclaimed defenders alike have deployed the term in a fashion. Nov 07, 2018 the following is an edited version of an internal document initially written in late 2015 and formed part of the basis for partywide discussions in the party for socialism and liberation in early 2016. Democratic centralism, decisionmaking practice and disciplinary policy adopted by the communist party of the soviet union cpsu and subsequently followed by the chinese communist party ccp and by communist parties in other countries democratic centralism purported to combine two opposing forms of party leadership.
Leonard schapiro begins his book, the origin of the communist autocracy,2 with the following statement. It was founded in 1921, chiefly by chen duxiu and li. Democratic centralism is the fundamental principle of economic management under socialism, in conformity with the relation of public socialist property to the means of production. The group of democratic centralism, sometimes called the group of 15, the decists, or the decemists, was a dissenting faction within the communist party of the soviet union in the early 1920s the group was formed in march 1919 at the 8th party congress.
Devoid of democratic content, the political and organizational logic of democratic centralism contributed to the emergence of dictatorship in the soviet union. Feb, 2007 the speech was given on the occasion of a reorganization of the structure of the cuban communist party. You have to keep in mind that russia is a much older civilization than the usa and the tradition of swearing at leaders and elders is considered very rude, let alone accusing the pr. The essence of democratic centralism lies in the combination of democracy and centralization. In this second, slightly edited edition of lenin and the. Compared with the usa, russia is at par or maybe more democratic. Although mainly associated with leninism, wherein the partys political vanguard composed of professional revolutionaries practised democratic centralism to elect leaders and officers as well as to determine policy through free discussion, then. Democratic centralism, the workers opposition, clandestine opposition movements, the crisis in the party, kronstadt and the end of the revolutionary period in russia michel olivier 1.
Democratic centralism is the application of marxist method to the question of how best to organize to lead the working class in the revolutionary transformation of society. Ap comparative government comparisons legitimacy britain huge due to tradition and gradualism russia yes, 1993 constitution, 2000 transition from yeltsin to putin china stable, military forces legitimacy, but citizens see it as corrupt mexico legitimate through pri in the early 20th century. The territory surrounding the russian federation is known in russia by. In this piece, nappalos examines everything from what lenin and gransci said on the subject, to what it looked like in practice in organizations such as the communist party usa and socialist workers party uk, among others. Democratic centralism in the communist party of cuba. Pdf the origins of democratic centralism ben lewis. The speech was given on the occasion of a reorganization of the structure of the cuban communist party. Democratic centralism purported to combine two opposing forms of party leadership.
Ap comparative government comparisons legitimacy britain huge due to tradition and gradualism russia yes, 1993 constitution, 2000 transition from yeltsin to putin china stable, military forces legitimacy, but citizens see it as corrupt. Upon becoming the ruling party after the october revolution 1917, the russian communist party extended democratic centralism to the. The group was formed in march 1919 at the 8th party congress. The principle of democratic centralism embraces all phases of reproduction. Democratic centralism requires that members have a firm, critical, and individual grasp of marxist theory and practice. At the 10th congress of the allrussian communist party 1921, the. Democratic centralism must be understood as a living process. The second defining characteristic of a communist system was democratic centralism, a key concept embodied in the published rules of communist parties which, in practice, signified centralism to the virtual exclusion of democracy. Democratic centralism article about democratic centralism. The following is an edited version of an internal document initially written in late 2015 and formed part of the basis for partywide discussions in the party for socialism and liberation in early 2016. The bolsheviks came to power in russia in 1917, whereas in 1918, they transformed themselves into a communist party. Democratic centralism is the organisational basis of the entire workers movement. The soviet union, 19171964 3 the emergence of communist dictatorship, 19171941 in this section, we will examine the nature of political authority in russia from. As of 2018 six parties have members in the federal parliament, the state duma, with one dominant party united russia.
Democratic centralism in stalin ussr the democratic aspect of this organizational method describes the freedom of members of the political party to discuss and debate matters of policy and direction, but once the decision of the party is made by majority vote, all members are expected to uphold that decision. Tensions within a peoples democratic dictatorship article pdf available in open journal of philosophy 0704. Luxemburg criticised the leninist idea of party organisation. This conception of the leninist principle of democratic centralist. Democratic centralism was a revolutionary strategy to reorganize society in china after 1949.
A democent in which an allpowerful party leadership regularly lets the party members applaud it at congresses and is otherwise uncontrollable, is an invention of the stalinists. Confronting realitylearning from the history of our movement. In spite of a decadelong history of studying the chinese model, most research failed to capture and generalize its essence in an accurate, concise and compelling way. Democratic centralism, the workers opposition, clandestine opposition movements, the crisis in the party, kronstadt and the end of the revolutionary period in russia michel olivier a short essay on the left opposition in the bolshevik party in russia from 1919 to 1927, focusing mostly on the democratic centralists and the workers opposition. Democratic centralism definition is a principle of communist party organization by which members take part in policy discussions and elections at all levels but must follow decisions made at higher levels. A comparative view of democratic centralism government and. Here are entered works on the communist principle of hierarchic organization which seeks to combine democratic participation by the membership with strict obedience to the decisions of higher units, and with absolute authority residing, in fact, at the apex of the hierarchic pyramid.
The cpc is the sole governing party within mainland china, permitting only eight other, subordinated parties to coexist, those making up the united front. Democratic centralism is a practice in which political decisions reached by voting processes. If someone doesnt do this, they are a strikebreaker. In explaining democratic centralism, each constitution reiterates that 1 party organizationb. Democratic centralism, decisionmaking practice and disciplinary policy adopted by the. The soviet policy of democratic centralism maintained that. Democratic centralism is a leninist idea which means that the ruling party in the case of russia, the bolsheviks would discuss an idea to come up with an answer, and then once an answer was decided discussion would never be allowed again. The sixth party congress of the russian socialdemocratic labour party bolsheviks held.
Democratic centralism tried to combine two opposing forms of party leadership. Social revolutionists needed not a mere parliamentary organization but a party of. Democratic centralism was adopted by the russian socialist workers party in 1906 wang 2002, 9. Democratic centralism is a practice in which political decisions reached by voting processes are binding upon all members of the political party. Youth and workers groups reports reveal a high degree of.
Confronting realitylearning from the history of our. I think lih goes too far in his claim that there was no connection between the way the term was used by lenin in 190607 and in 192021, as well as in. Russia, along with brazil, india, and china, is considered to be one of the worlds emerging economies, and is grouped with these countries under what acronym. Democratic centralism is perhaps one of the most maligned, misunderstood and controversial terms in the contemporary marxist vernacular. The communist party of china cpc is the founding and ruling political party of the peoples republic of china prc and the second largest political party in the world. French danone bought the firm soon after it was privatized, and it is now one of the most successful cookie brands in russia. As of 2018 six parties have members in the federal parliament, the state duma, with one dominant party united russia after the perestroika reforms in the 1980s russia had over 100 registered parties, but the people elected to the state duma represented only a small number. Democratic centralism definition of democratic centralism. Can democratic centralism be conducive to democracy. Political rights a 198586 1991 92 1994 95 1998 99 200001 1 2 3 4 5 6 rating source. I begin from the outside per spective, drawing on john rawlss idea of. Outside russia, some of the prominent marxist leaders like karl kautsky and rosa. Joseph stalin used this principle to help him rise to power in the 1920s. Commissars were posted to government institutions, thereby.
Rawls is famous for his arguments about what conception of justice a lib. Democratic centralism means that the individual party member always and under all circumstances must subordinate himself in his public action and expression to the policy and decisions of the party. Bolshevism, fraudulent practice of democratic centralism. An exhaustive article by scott nappalos on the leninist conception of democratic centralism.
At the 10th congress of the allrussian communist party 1921, the bolshevik leader vladimir ilich lenin declared that the party was not a. At the 10th congress of the all russian communist party 1921, the bolshevik leader vladimir ilich lenin declared that the party was not a. Crafting a theory of socialist democracy for china in the. Russia, 18551964 a as level history for aqa student book hannah dalton series editors. Similarly in russia, the theoretical doc trine of socialdemocracy arose quite. For example, if after a democratic discussion a factory assembly decides to go on strike, everyone must implement this decision. Social revolutionists needed not a mere parliamentary organization but a party of action which would function as a. Democratic centralism barrow major reference works wiley. Democratic centralism thence appeared in china as a cpc rule in 1927, and two key cpc constitutions from july 1928 and june 1945 include statements on democratic centralism as a basic principle of party organization. We should say there are many democratic centralisms rather. The document examines the new possibilities and difficulties posed by the proliferation of social media from the perspective of the leninist. The principles of democratic centralism do not provide a standard blueprint for communist organization, but rather an approach to the process of. Democratic centralism, the workers opposition, clandestine.
Among the exceptional circumstances are when the party form does not centrally correspond with the revolutionary marxist program. Chapter 1 from democratic centralism to democratic centralism pp. It is strange that the story of political opposition to lenin has never before, so far as i am. In this paper, i contend democratic centralism, the core mechanism in chinas system of government, could very well summarize and represent the fundamental elements of chinese model. Third, democratic centralism is able to optimize the relationship between democracy and efficiency.
The group of democratic centralism, sometimes called the group of 15, the decists, or the decemists, was a dissenting faction within the communist party of the soviet union in the early 1920s. The main body of the letter is an outline of some of the main ideas of the april theses, and a request that she acquaint several comrades with a draft of a set of theses about the political situation. Because of the commitments to democratic centralism and to the theoretical selfunderstanding as a vanguard party, communists could only be cadres, although in a sense distinct from the usage of this term introduced into political science by maurice duverger. Without democratic centralism, the integration of the three can only exist in principle but not in practice. Despite the formal ban, in the early 1920s factions emerged in the party because lenin failed to work out orderly procedures for leadership succession see soviet union ussr the era of. Democratic centralism lived and changed across its life beginning with russian social democracy and evolved to become a dominant political class with a monopoly of power and illegalized all political opposition.
In the course of explaining the restructuring, castro gives a lucid explanation of the theory and practice of democratic centralism, the guiding norm for revolutionary organizations modeled on leninist lines. Documents of the 1968 is conferences as ever i am most grateful to john rudge for locating and editing these documents. Decent democratic centralism article pdf available in political theory 334. Although often distinguished by communist theorists from. Democratic centralism the paramount principle of organizational structure, activity, and leadership of marxistleninist parties, the socialist state, and the management of a socialist economy. If too many members lack these abilities, the party will lack that dialogue between members and leaders, base and center, party and masses, that is essential to democratic centralist decision making, practice, and evaluation. This essay explores the tensions between democracy and centralization in the practice of democratic centralism in 1950s shanghai. To oppose the new government was considered treason. In our greetings to your conference, we spoke of certain exceptional circumstances in connection with the application of democratic centralism among revolutionaries. This article discusses political parties in russia the russian federation has a multiparty system.
923 1132 854 1328 1595 1073 1077 293 622 1188 1258 704 393 376 1571 322 290 36 1456 277 944 1448 1327 1510 214 293 817 35 695 1623 595 188 1394 594 1408 1256 57 898 651 307 126